Court Rejects Anonymous Sexual Assault Claim Against Blank Rome LLP

2 min readSources: Volokh Conspiracy

A court denied an ex-associate's pseudonymity in a sexual assault claim against Blank Rome LLP.

Why it matters: This ruling highlights the challenge of balancing victim privacy with defendants' rights in high-profile misconduct cases. It sets a benchmark on when courts allow anonymity in sensitive lawsuits involving large firms.

  • Former Blank Rome LLP associate filed a sexual assault and discrimination lawsuit under pseudonym "Jane Doe".
  • Judge W. Scott Hardy denied the anonymity request, citing fairness and the rule that parties litigate publicly.
  • The complaint had 197 paragraphs with detailed facts that could reveal identities despite pseudonymity.
  • The case was dismissed months later, likely after settlement; identities remain undisclosed.

A former associate at Blank Rome LLP brought a lawsuit alleging sexual assault by another associate and claims of sex discrimination, hostile work environment, and retaliation under Title VII. The incident reportedly occurred during socializing at a partner's home after a graduation party. The plaintiff filed under the pseudonym "Jane Doe," while naming the firm and its Chief Human Resource Officer multiple times.

Judge W. Scott Hardy ruled against allowing the plaintiff to proceed anonymously, emphasizing the legal principle that parties are generally required to litigate under their real names. He stated, "Permitting Doe to proceed pseudonymously while the Firm defends itself publicly... presents an unfair asymmetry that also weighs against anonymity." The court also noted that embarrassment or potential economic harm does not justify anonymity in this context.

The plaintiff's 197-paragraph complaint contained extensive details on professional backgrounds of herself and the accused associate—including education and work history—that could effectively identify them, further undermining the anonymity claim.

The case was dismissed a few months after this ruling, presumably settling out of court. Neither the plaintiff nor the accused associate were publicly named in the record following dismissal.

This decision underscores judicial caution about one-sided pseudonym use in sexual assault and discrimination claims against major firms, aiming to protect the fairness and transparency of the legal process where serious factual disputes exist.

By the numbers:

  • 197 paragraphs — length of the plaintiff's detailed complaint
  • 24 times — mentions of the firm's Chief Human Resource Officer in the complaint

Yes, but: While protecting victims' privacy is critical, courts will deny anonymity if it creates unfair disadvantages for defendants or obscures public accountability.