Developer Challenges Denver's Affordable Housing Fees as Costly
Developer redT appeals Denver affordable housing fees to the 10th Circuit, claiming they raise housing costs.
Why it matters: This case could reshape affordable housing policies affecting legal counsel for developers, municipalities, and housing advocates. It highlights legal tensions over cost and regulatory compliance in real estate development.
- redT filed an appeal with the 10th Circuit on Nov 16, 2026, challenging Denver's affordable housing ordinance.
- Denver mandates developers to pay linkage fees from $1.99 to $7.22 per sq ft or allocate 10% units at below-market rates for 99 years.
- redT argues fees can reach $70,000 per permit, increasing costs for 'attainably priced' LEED homes.
- A district court dismissed redT's lawsuit in Mar 2026; redT now claims the ordinance is an unconstitutional taking of property.
On November 16, 2026, Colorado developer redT filed an appeal with the 10th Circuit Court opposing Denver's affordable housing program. This ordinance requires developers either to pay linkage fees between $1.99 and $7.22 per square foot, or to designate 10% of new project units as below-market-rate for 99 years.
According to attorney David Deerson of the Pacific Legal Foundation, which represents redT, the city "refuses to issue a permit to redT to construct a home until they pay $70,000 in fees." RedT argues these fees inadvertently increase costs for "attainably priced" LEED-certified homes, raising questions about the impact on housing affordability.
RedT's earlier lawsuit, dismissed in March 2026 by U.S. District Judge Philip Brimmer, alleged that Denver's mandates constitute an unconstitutional taking of property. The developer now presses this argument in the appellate court, contending the fee and unit set-aside requirements impose unjust restrictions that "run with the land," as noted by U.S. Circuit Judge Harris Hartz.
This legal challenge exposes the tension between regulatory efforts to increase affordable housing and the cost burdens on developers. The 10th Circuit's reconsideration could set significant precedent on the constitutional limits of municipal affordable housing policies, affecting how legal teams advise clients on development strategies and regulatory compliance.
By the numbers:
- $1.99 to $7.22 per square foot — range of Denver's linkage fees
- 10% of units — required below-market set-aside for 99 years
- Up to $70,000 per permit — potential fee developers like redT face
- March 2026 — district court dismissal of redT's initial lawsuit
- November 16, 2026 — date redT filed its appeal to the 10th Circuit
Yes, but: While the ordinance aims to increase affordable housing stock, its implementation raises legal and financial concerns about fairness and property rights.
What's next: The 10th Circuit's ruling on redT's appeal will be closely watched for its impact on affordable housing policies and real estate development regulations across the region.