DOJ Barred from Pressuring Apple, Facebook to Censor ICE Tracking Apps
A federal court barred DOJ and DHS from pressuring Apple and Facebook to censor ICE tracking apps and groups.
Why it matters: This ruling limits government influence on private tech companies’ content moderation, protecting free speech about law enforcement. It sets a key First Amendment precedent against government coercion through third parties.
- Permanent injunction issued Nov 13, 2026, by U.S. District Judge Jorge L. Alonso.
- DOJ and DHS pressured Apple and Facebook in October 2025 to remove the 'Eyes Up' app and disable 'ICE Sightings – Chicagoland' Facebook group.
- The 'Eyes Up' app shares videos of ICE operations; the Facebook group reports ICE activity in Chicago.
- FIRE filed the lawsuit in February 2026; a preliminary injunction was granted in April before the permanent ban.
On November 13, 2026, U.S. District Judge Jorge L. Alonso granted a permanent injunction prohibiting the Department of Justice (DOJ) and Department of Homeland Security (DHS) from pressuring Apple and Facebook to remove or disable platforms that monitor Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) activities. The ruling protects two digital platforms: the Eyes Up app and the ICE Sightings – Chicagoland Facebook group.
The Eyes Up app, developed by Mark Hodges, allows users to upload videos documenting ICE operations. The Facebook group, started in January 2025 by Kae Rosado, lets Chicago-area residents report ICE presence. In October 2025, federal officials pressured Apple to remove the app and Facebook to disable the group, actions which sparked controversy over government overreach.
In response, the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) filed suit on behalf of Hodges and Rosado in February 2026. They alleged that DOJ and DHS infringed the First Amendment by coercing private companies to suppress protected speech. A preliminary injunction was granted in April 2026, signaling the court’s skepticism of the government’s position.
The permanent injunction now requires DOJ and DHS to refrain from both formal and informal demands to Apple and Facebook about censoring these platforms. Officials must also alert their internal teams within seven days to ensure compliance.
Mark Hodges stated, "The government targeting my speech was wrong, and this ruling affirms our constitutional rights." Kae Rosado added, "Our ability to speak freely about government actions without fear of retaliation is vital for democracy." Colin McDonell, FIRE’s senior attorney, told The Nation, "The First Amendment protects sharing truthful information about government activities." An independent analysis by Lawfare agrees this decision sets an important precedent limiting government influence over digital platforms.
This case highlights constitutional limits on government attempts to control speech by pressuring private technology companies. It reinforces political speech protections, particularly when the speech exposes law enforcement conduct.
By the numbers:
- Nov 13, 2026 — Date of U.S. District Court’s permanent injunction.
- Oct 2025 — DOJ and DHS pressured Apple and Facebook to censor platforms.
- Feb 2026 — FIRE filed lawsuit challenging government coercion.
- April 2026 — Court issued preliminary injunction favoring plaintiffs.
Yes, but: While the injunction restricts formal and informal government demands to tech companies, it does not limit private companies’ independent content moderation policies.
What's next: Potential appeals from DOJ or DHS may follow; the case could set a precedent for challenges to government-coerced content removal on other platforms.