DOJ Proposal May Ease Injunctions for Patent Trolls, Raising Concerns
DOJ and USPTO's March 2026 filing supports broader injunction rights for all patent holders, including patent trolls.
Why it matters: Patent litigators and legal tech professionals should track DOJ's stance as it could increase injunction use by non-practicing entities, altering litigation risks and costs.
- In March 2026, DOJ and USPTO jointly filed a Statement of Interest backing broad injunction access in Collision Communications Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co.
- The DOJ's Antitrust Division clarified that holding a patent does not automatically grant market power, urging careful antitrust enforcement in patent disputes.
- EFF warned in April 2026 that DOJ's proposal risks empowering patent assertion entities (PAEs), often viewed as patent trolls, to obtain injunctions more readily.
- EFF advocates reforms to prevent abusive leverage by PAEs that may hinder innovation and drive up litigation expenses.
In March 2026, the Department of Justice (DOJ) and the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) jointly submitted a Statement of Interest in Collision Communications Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. The filing argued for maintaining broad access to injunctions, which are court orders to stop alleged patent infringers, for all patent holders—including non-practicing entities (NPEs), sometimes called patent trolls.
The DOJ and USPTO asserted that restricting injunctions for these entities could negatively affect innovation incentives. Injunctions are a powerful tool in patent enforcement, allowing patent holders to halt infringing products quickly, beyond monetary damages.
Shortly before, the DOJ’s Antitrust Division issued an analysis clarifying that owning a patent does not automatically equate to holding market power. They cautioned against overusing antitrust laws to intervene in typical patent licensing or enforcement disputes, emphasizing the need to carefully balance intellectual property rights and competition policy (Wiley Law, March 2026).
However, in April 2026, the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) issued a warning. It highlighted concerns that easing injunction access could enable patent assertion entities—entities that typically license patents but do not manufacture products—to leverage courts for abusive litigation tactics. These patent trolls are known for pursuing settlements through the threat of injunctions rather than valid enforcement against genuine infringement.
EFF urged policymakers to enact reforms to ensure injunctions remain tools for legitimate innovators, not for entities seeking to extract unwarranted settlements that increase litigation costs and impede technological progress.
By the numbers:
- March 2026 — DOJ and USPTO joint filing supporting broad injunction rights
- April 2026 — EFF public warning about enhanced injunction risks for patent trolls
- Case name — Collision Communications Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co.
Yes, but: While DOJ supports broad injunction rights to protect innovation incentives, critics argue this risks empowering entities whose primary business is litigation rather than innovation.
What's next: Legal professionals should monitor developments in Collision Communications litigation and potential legislative or regulatory responses addressing injunction use.