Federal Judge Allows False Advertising Suit Over Baby Food Labels to Proceed
A federal judge in California reinstated a false advertising suit over Once Upon a Farm's organic baby food pouch labeling.
Why it matters: The ruling highlights legal scrutiny around food marketing claims, affecting legal teams advising consumer brands on labeling practices.
- Judge Edward M. Chen reversed an earlier dismissal on November 16, 2026, allowing the lawsuit to proceed.
- The lawsuit challenges Once Upon a Farm’s 'Wild Rumpus Avocado' pouch marketed as an 'Organic Fruit & Veggie Blend.'
- FDA classifies avocado as a fruit and mint as an herb, so the product contains no vegetables.
- Once Upon a Farm went public in February 2026 and distributes products in over 22,000 stores nationwide.
On November 16, 2026, U.S. District Judge Edward M. Chen reversed his previous dismissal of a false advertising class action lawsuit against Once Upon a Farm, allowing the dispute to move forward.
The suit, filed by consumer Alexa Parashos, targets the labeling of the company’s "Wild Rumpus Avocado" organic food pouch. It is marketed as an "Organic Fruit & Veggie Blend," but the ingredients include pineapple, banana, apple, avocado, and mint. The FDA classifies avocado as a fruit and mint as an herb, meaning the product contains no vegetables.
Judge Chen cited the Ninth Circuit’s 2024 decision in Whiteside v. Kimberly Clark Corp. as influential in his reversal. He noted, "Fruit & Veggie Blend is not a 'meaningless marketing term' that the consumer would necessarily need more information to understand." He added, "The very fact that a reasonable consumer could reasonably conclude that the product contains a vegetable other than avocados is sufficient to state a claim of falsity without requiring consumers to read the back label."
Founded in 2011, Once Upon a Farm went public earlier in 2026. Its products are widely available in over 22,000 stores across the United States.
This case underscores growing legal challenges around food marketing claims, especially in the organic and health-focused sectors, and signals careful attention for in-house counsel and outside legal teams advising consumer brands on advertising and product labeling.
By the numbers:
- 22,000+ stores — nationwide availability of Once Upon a Farm products
- February 2026 — Once Upon a Farm went public
- November 16, 2026 — Judge Chen reversed dismissal of false advertising suit