Fifth Circuit Strikes Down Texas House Proxy Voting Rule from COVID Era
The full Fifth Circuit invalidated the Texas House's COVID proxy voting rule as unconstitutional.
Why it matters: This ruling challenges emergency legislative procedures used during the pandemic, affecting how legislatures may conduct business in crises. Legal professionals must consider its implications on constitutional law and governance protocols.
- The ruling was issued November 20, 2026, by the en banc U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit.
- The proxy voting rule allowed absent House members to vote by proxy, counting towards a quorum during the COVID pandemic.
- Judge Cory Wilson's majority opinion held physical presence is required by the Constitution's Quorum Clause.
- A dissent by Judge James E. Graves Jr. argued the House can set its own rules and physical presence isn’t mandated.
On November 20, 2026, the en banc Fifth Circuit struck down the proxy voting rule implemented by the U.S. House during the COVID-19 pandemic as unconstitutional. The rule had enabled members absent due to health concerns to cast votes by proxy, counting them as present to meet quorum requirements.
The court’s majority opinion, authored by Judge Cory Wilson, emphasized that the Constitution's Quorum Clause requires members to be physically present to establish a quorum. Wilson wrote, "The Quorum Clause's text, context, original understanding, and unbroken historical application all indicate that Members of Congress must be present for quorum purposes... 'Proxy presence' does not count."
This proxy voting had supported the passage of significant legislation, including the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023. For that Act, 226 proxy votes were cast alongside 205 in-person votes, with the final tally at 225 yeas, 201 nays, 1 present, and 4 non-votes.
The ruling also directly impacted the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA), a provision within the appropriations bill, by enjoining its enforcement in Texas. This sets a precedent for questioning other laws passed under similar proxy procedures.
However, the court was divided. Judge James E. Graves Jr. dissented, contending that the Constitution grants the House authority to determine procedural rules and does not explicitly require physical presence for quorum, stating, "The conclusion that '[t]he Quorum Clause is concerned with physical presence' shoehorns a much larger requirement into the Constitution."
This decision raises questions about the validity of other emergency rules used during the pandemic and may prompt further litigation or appeals, potentially reaching the U.S. Supreme Court.
By the numbers:
- November 20, 2026 — Date of the en banc Fifth Circuit ruling
- 226 proxy votes — Cast during the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 vote
- 205 in-person votes — Counted alongside proxy votes during the same vote
Yes, but: The dissent underscores ongoing debate over congressional rulemaking power, suggesting the ruling could be challenged further.
What's next: The ruling's future impact may hinge on potential appeals to the U.S. Supreme Court and its effect on emergency governance frameworks.