Fourth Circuit Divides Deeply Over Kalshi Preemption, Issuing 4 Opinions

3 min readSources: Volokh Conspiracy

Fourth Circuit panel issues four separate opinions on Kalshi's preemption challenge.

Why it matters: How courts interpret preemption in emerging prediction markets affects compliance and litigation strategies for legal practitioners.

  • On Nov. 18, 2026, Fourth Circuit affirmed denial of Kalshi's preliminary injunction against Maryland sports wagering law enforcement.
  • Three-judge panel produced a per curiam affirmance, two concurrences by Judges Gregory and Thacker, and a dissent by Judge Benjamin.
  • Judge Gregory assumed Kalshi's contracts are 'swaps' but found no clear federal preemption over state gambling laws.
  • Judge Benjamin dissented, arguing the Commodity Exchange Act preempts Maryland's gambling laws for Kalshi's contracts.

On November 18, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit issued a per curiam opinion affirming the district court's denial of KalshiEX LLC's request for a preliminary injunction against Maryland's enforcement of its sports wagering laws.

The three-judge panel produced four separate opinions, demonstrating a significant judicial split. There was a per curiam affirmance, two concurring opinions by Judges Roger Gregory and Stephanie Thacker, and a dissenting opinion by Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin.

  • Judge Gregory concurred, assuming without deciding that Kalshi's sports event contracts qualify as "swaps" under the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA). However, he concluded that the CEA does not clearly preempt Maryland's authority to regulate gambling. As he stated, "Because the regulation of gambling has long been a matter of traditional state police power, I would not infer that Congress displaced Maryland's concurrent authority absent a clear expression of its intent to do so."
  • Judge Thacker also concurred but determined Kalshi's sports event contracts are not "swaps" under the CEA because they fail to meet the statutory definition requiring payments to depend on the occurrence of an event with financial consequences. She noted plainly, "What is happening here is sports betting. That is gambling, plain and simple."
  • In contrast, Judge Benjamin dissented, arguing Kalshi's contracts are "swaps" under the CEA, granting the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) exclusive jurisdiction. She emphasized, "This case concerns whether the Commodity Exchange Act preempts Maryland's application of its gambling laws to KalshiEX's sports-related event contracts traded on a federally regulated exchange."

This Fourth Circuit ruling aligns with prior opinions from the Sixth and Ninth Circuits, which also rejected Kalshi's preemption arguments. However, it diverges from the Third Circuit, which previously found in favor of federal preemption supporting Kalshi's position.

Kalshi's business model, operating federally regulated prediction markets with contracts on sports outcomes, sits at the intersection of gambling regulation and securities law. States like Maryland have challenged it as illegal gambling, while Kalshi argues for federal preemption under the CEA. This fractured decision underscores continuing judicial uncertainty over how innovative markets will be regulated.

By the numbers:

  • November 18, 2026 — Fourth Circuit decision date
  • April 21, 2025 — Kalshi filed lawsuit against Maryland officials
  • May 7, 2026 — Date of oral arguments in the Fourth Circuit

Yes, but: While the Fourth Circuit panel disagreed internally, the court collectively declined to block Maryland's enforcement of its gambling statutes against Kalshi at this stage.

What's next: Kalshi may pursue further appeals, potentially seeking en banc review or Supreme Court intervention to resolve circuit splits on preemption.