Fourth Circuit Upholds Maryland’s Gambling Laws Against Kalshi
Fourth Circuit ruled against Kalshi, affirming Maryland’s regulation of its prediction market.
Why it matters: This ruling clarifies that state gambling laws apply to prediction markets, raising compliance risks and potential litigation costs for operators and their legal advisors.
- On Nov. 17, 2026, Fourth Circuit denied Kalshi’s preliminary injunction request in a 2-1 decision.
- The court held Kalshi’s event contracts fall under Maryland’s gambling laws and state regulatory authority.
- Judges Gregory and Thacker concurred on ruling but differed on legal reasoning; Judge Benjamin dissented.
- Ruling contributes to circuit split on state regulation of prediction markets, increasing chance of Supreme Court review.
On November 17, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit rejected Kalshi’s challenge to Maryland’s enforcement of its gambling laws, denying Kalshi’s request for a preliminary injunction that sought to pause state regulation. This affirms Maryland's authority to regulate Kalshi’s prediction market contracts.
The court determined that Kalshi’s contracts—financial bets on event outcomes like sports or political events—are subject to Maryland’s gambling laws. It held that these contracts constitute gambling under state law and do not receive federal immunity. Notably, the court referenced Kalshi’s marketing practices as linked to unlawful gambling activity, framing the case within consumer protection concerns tied to state gambling enforcement.
Judges Roger Gregory and Stephanie Thacker both voted to deny the injunction but wrote separate opinions outlining different legal rationales supporting Maryland’s regulatory authority. Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin dissented, voicing constitutional objections regarding state regulation.
Maryland Attorney General Anthony G. Brown praised the decision, emphasizing that Kalshi must comply with the same consumer protection and operational standards as traditional sportsbooks. Brown said this ensures that "gambling remains fair and safe for Marylanders." The ruling underscores the role of state oversight in protecting bettors and maintaining market integrity.
This decision adds to a growing split among federal appellate courts on whether states may regulate prediction markets under gambling laws. Some circuits broadly support states’ rights to regulate these platforms, while others restrict such authority. This division makes Supreme Court review increasingly likely, which could set a uniform national standard.
For legal professionals advising clients offering prediction markets or similar financial platforms, this ruling highlights the importance of closely tracking state regulations. Even with federal statutes in play, operators face significant compliance and litigation risks under diverse state gambling laws.
The Fourth Circuit’s official opinion in case No. 23-1824 provides a detailed explanation of the majority and dissenting views, valuable for understanding the evolving legal landscape governing prediction markets.
By the numbers:
- 2-1 vote — Fourth Circuit panel decision on Nov. 17, 2026
- 23-1824 — Federal appellate case number for Kalshi litigation
- Several circuits — Involved in split over state gambling regulation of prediction markets
Yes, but: While the court emphasized gambling law enforcement, the phrase 'deceptive advertising' relates to Kalshi’s marketing tied to these unlawful gambling contracts and should not be mistaken as a separate deceptive advertising claim.
What's next: The divergent appellate rulings increase the likelihood the U.S. Supreme Court will decide on the scope of state regulation of prediction markets in the near future, potentially setting nationwide legal standards.