Trump Admin Challenges Block on Federal Building Noise Rules

3 min readSources: Courthouse News

The Trump administration moves to overturn a block on DHS noise regulations near federal sites.

Why it matters: The case highlights conflict between protest rights and federal security rules. It's crucial for legal professionals focusing on constitutional law and regulatory policy to watch these developments.

  • June 2025: DHS enacted new rules banning loud or unusual noises on and near federal property.
  • November 2025: Regulations' effective date accelerated to immediate enforcement.
  • Plaintiffs filed suit alleging the rules chill free speech on public sidewalks near federal buildings.
  • Ninth Circuit questioned the regulations' broad officer discretion to limit protests.
  • Trump administration seeks reversal of the block on these regulations.

In June 2025, the Department of Homeland Security finalized new regulations under 6 C.F.R. 139.35(c) that prohibit 'creating a loud or unusual noise, noxious odor, or other nuisance' on federal property and nearby areas that affect federal property or personnel. This expanded previous rules by extending the geographic scope beyond federal grounds. The official rule text outlines these restrictions.

On November 5, 2025, the government moved to accelerate the rules' effective date immediately, increasing enforcement risk. Protesters Chloe Longworth and Anna Lardner, who regularly demonstrate on city sidewalks in front of the Eugene, Oregon federal building, filed suit challenging these regulations. They argue the rules chill constitutionally protected speech in traditional public forums, namely public sidewalks.Their legal challenge asserts the government is criminalizing speech based on noise levels, impacting First Amendment rights.

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals weighed in April 2026 in Dickinson v. Trump, questioning whether the DHS regulations grant officers excessive discretion to restrict protests. Circuit Judge Kenneth K. Lee emphasized, "The First Amendment enshrines the right of the people to peacefully protest our government's policies," but noted this does not shield illegal acts such as trespass or obstruction of law enforcement.The Ninth Circuit's concerns underpin the current dispute.

Now, the Trump administration is seeking to overturn the court's block on enforcement of these noise regulations, aiming to uphold DHS's expanded authority. This case underscores fundamental tensions between maintaining federal building security and protecting protest rights.

By the numbers:

  • June 2025 — DHS finalized new noise regulations under 6 C.F.R. 139.35(c)
  • November 5, 2025 — Effective date of regulations accelerated to immediate enforcement
  • December 10, 2025 — Lawsuit filed challenging the new regulations
  • April 27, 2026 — Ninth Circuit issued order questioning officer discretion in enforcing the rules

Yes, but: While the regulations aim to protect federal property and personnel, critics argue the vague language invites excessive officer discretion, possibly infringing on free speech.

What's next: The Trump administration's appeal seeks to reverse the Ninth Circuit's injunction, with further judicial rulings expected on the scope of protest restrictions near federal sites.