USPTO Shifts Merits-Based Patent Review Back to PTAB Panels

3 min readSources: National Law Review

Starting November 16, 2026, PTAB panels will handle merits-based institution decisions for IPR and PGR.

Why it matters: This change affects how patent challenges are assessed, influencing litigation risk and legal strategy for IP professionals.

  • USPTO memorandum issued November 10, 2026, reinstates merits-based institution decisions to PTAB starting November 16.
  • PTAB judges contributed to over 325 merits-based decisions in the past year, demonstrating expertise.
  • Institution requires a 'substantial majority' of challenged claims meet the standard; failure leads to denial.
  • Director retains oversight of discretionary considerations but delegates technical merits decisions to PTAB panels.

On November 10, 2026, USPTO Director John A. Squires and General Counsel John F. Duffy announced that effective November 16, the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) will resume making merits-based decisions for instituting inter partes review (IPR) and post-grant review (PGR) proceedings.

This signals a shift from the centralized approach adopted in October 2025, when Director Squires assumed sole authority over institution decisions to enhance policy consistency. The PTAB will now review merits-based considerations, leveraging their technical expertise. The Director will still oversee discretionary factors, maintaining strategic control.

The updated process applies to IPR or PGR petitions filed before the notice of institution for merits consideration is issued. A three-judge PTAB panel decides whether to institute a proceeding based on whether a "substantial majority" of challenged claims satisfy the institution standard. If the petitioner cannot meet this burden, the panel must deny institution. Similarly, a patent owner’s preliminary response presenting a "reasonable argument, well-supported with reliable, credible evidence" can lead to denial for a substantial majority of claims.

By separating panels for institution and trial phases, the USPTO aims to prevent bias or preconceived notions from affecting the trial's outcome. This merits-based framework seeks to improve patent quality and procedural clarity, influenced in part by programs such as LOOP (Learning from Outcomes to Optimize Patents) and PTAB STRONG, which provided training linking trial lessons to patent examination.

Attorney Suni Sukduang explained that the return to merits-based decisions does not revive prior practices wholesale, but mandates denial if weaknesses affect a substantial majority of claims, emphasizing rigor in reviewing petitions. Morrison & Foerster LLP also noted the USPTO's memorandum guidelines are illustrative and build on prior Director decisions applying these principles.

IP lawyers and patent strategists should closely monitor this procedural evolution, as it may impact institution rates and patent challenge outcomes, altering litigation risk profiles and USPTO proceedings.

By the numbers:

  • 325+ decisions involving merits-based consideration by PTAB judges in past year
  • November 16, 2026 — effective date of reinstating merits-based institution decisions
  • "Substantial majority" standard now required for instituting IPR and PGR proceedings

Yes, but: The memorandum does not precisely define "substantial majority," leaving some uncertainty about the threshold that triggers denial.

What's next: Observe upcoming PTAB institution decisions for emerging trends on how the "substantial majority" standard is applied and its impact on patent challenges.