W.D. Texas Sticks to Treating Texts as Calls in TCPA Lawsuit Against The General

2 min readSources: National Law Review

Western District of Texas refuses to change its TCPA SMS text message ruling in The General's case.

Why it matters: The ruling solidifies a key interpretation of TCPA regulations affecting how companies handle SMS marketing and impacts litigation approaches in telecommunications and insurance sectors.

  • Western District of Texas holds texts are 'telephone calls' under TCPA Do-Not-Call (DNC) rules.
  • Court rejected defendant's motion for judgment in Feliciano v. Red McCombs, maintaining SMS coverage by TCPA.
  • Contrasting courts: Seventh Circuit ruled texts aren't calls (July 2026) while Southern District of Texas dismissed similar TCPA claims (Nov 2026).
  • The split adds complexity for companies navigating TCPA compliance and lawsuits, especially in SMS marketing.

The Western District of Texas has reaffirmed that text messages qualify as 'telephone calls' under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act's Do-Not-Call (DNC) provisions. This comes in the ongoing litigation context involving The General's lawsuits, where the court denied a defendant's motion for judgment on the pleadings in Feliciano v. Red McCombs.

This ruling means that SMS messages fall within the TCPA's DNC rules, requiring businesses to carefully navigate consent and opt-out mandates for text communications. Eric J. Troutman, attorney at Troutman Amin, LLP, emphasized the court's position, stating the district "isn't budging" on the classification of texts as calls.

However, there is a noted judicial split. The Seventh Circuit, in Steidinger v. Blackstone Medical Services, ruled on July 14, 2026, that text messages do not constitute "telephone calls" under the TCPA's DNC provisions. Additionally, the Southern District of Texas dismissed TCPA claims in Siringi v. Crust Pizza Co. in November 2026, concluding texts fall outside the TCPA's private right of action.

Jeffrey Backman of Greenspoon Marder LLP noted this division highlights the importance of the statutory language and ongoing legal interpretations shaping TCPA enforcement. For telecommunications and insurance companies, especially those using SMS marketing like The General, these differing rulings create legal ambiguity and complicate compliance efforts.

By the numbers:

  • July 14, 2026 — Seventh Circuit ruled texts aren't "telephone calls" under TCPA DNC rules
  • November 6, 2026 — Southern District of Texas dismissed TCPA texting claims

Yes, but: While W.D. Texas maintains texts are calls under TCPA, other jurisdictions have ruled otherwise, creating legal uncertainty.