Epstein Victims Push to Revive Lawsuit Against BNY Mellon; Court Skeptical

3 min readSources: Courthouse News

Second Circuit considers renewed suit against BNY Mellon over Epstein-related claims.

Why it matters: Financial institutions face complex legal risks when linked to client crimes. This case highlights the challenge of proving direct liability amid long-delayed reporting of suspicious transactions.

  • On November 18, 2026, the Second Circuit heard arguments to revive Epstein victims' suit against BNY Mellon.
  • The lawsuit alleges BNY Mellon processed suspicious transactions facilitating Epstein’s sex trafficking without proper oversight.
  • Senator Ron Wyden’s investigation uncovered $378 million moved via 270 suspicious wire transfers in BNY Mellon accounts.
  • The bank reported these transactions to the Treasury only in 2019, over a decade late, potentially violating anti-money laundering laws.
  • The appellate panel expressed skepticism about BNY Mellon being sufficiently close to Epstein’s crimes for liability.

On November 18, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit heard oral arguments on whether to revive a lawsuit filed by Jeffrey Epstein’s victims against Bank of New York Mellon (BNY Mellon). The suit claims the bank facilitated Epstein’s sex trafficking by processing suspicious financial transactions without proper oversight.

Earlier in January 2026, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York dismissed the case, leading to the current appeal. The plaintiffs seek to hold BNY Mellon accountable for allegedly enabling Epstein’s criminal activities through its banking services.

An investigation led by Senator Ron Wyden, Ranking Member of the Senate Finance Committee, revealed Epstein moved $378 million through 270 wire transfers in BNY Mellon accounts. Many transfers lacked legitimate business purposes and showed patterns consistent with money laundering. The bank did not report these suspicious transactions to the Treasury Department until 2019, more than ten years after they occurred, raising serious questions about compliance with the Bank Secrecy Act.

During oral arguments, the appellate panel expressed doubt over whether BNY Mellon was legally close enough to Epstein’s crimes to justify liability. As reporter Erik Uebelacker noted, the judges' skepticism signals the high bar plaintiffs face in proving direct involvement by financial institutions in their clients’ wrongdoing.

This case is part of a broader legal struggle to define the extent to which banks and financial institutions can be held accountable for facilitating illicit activity, particularly when suspicious conduct goes unreported for years. It follows previous suits, such as Bank of America’s $72.5 million settlement with Epstein’s victims, underscoring the stakes involved for both litigators and compliance officers in managing financial crime risk.

By the numbers:

  • $378 million — Epstein funds moved via BNY Mellon accounts
  • 270 wire transfers — Transactions flagged as suspicious in Senate investigation
  • 10+ years — Delay before BNY Mellon reported suspicious activity

Yes, but: The Second Circuit's skepticism reflects the legal challenge of establishing proximate liability for banks when wrongdoing is indirect or obscured by layers of transactions.

What's next: The timeline for the court's decision on reviving the lawsuit remains uncertain.