Judge Voids NMFS Wildlife Review for American Samoa Deep-Sea Mining
A judge vacated the wildlife review for American Samoa deep-sea mining leases as improperly narrow.
Why it matters: This ruling enforces stricter environmental reviews under the Endangered Species Act, impacting mining lease approvals and regulatory oversight for resource extraction projects.
- Judge Jill Otake ruled on Nov 16, 2026, that NMFS violated the Endangered Species Act by limiting review to preliminary surveying.
- The lease sale, called PACM-1, covers about 31 million acres off American Samoa and was scheduled for Nov 19, 2026.
- Judge Otake vacated NMFS's Letter of Concurrence that found no likely adverse effects on protected species.
- The area includes dozens of endangered species, including whales, sea turtles, sharks, manta rays, nautilus, and coral species.
On November 16, 2026, U.S. District Judge Jill Otake vacated the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) Letter of Concurrence approving the proposed deep-sea mining lease sale off American Samoa, ruling the agency's environmental review was too narrow. Instead of assessing the full potential impacts, NMFS limited its review to preliminary surveying activities, which the court found violated the Endangered Species Act.
The lease sale PACM-1 covers approximately 31 million acres of seabed adjacent to American Samoa and was set for auction on November 19, 2026. It includes two auction areas of roughly 16.3 million and 15.2 million acres, with a minimum bid of $3 million each, under the Marine Minerals Administration, the agency now managing these leasing activities. The region harbors numerous protected species including blue, fin, sei, and sperm whales; five sea turtle species; oceanic whitetip and scalloped hammerhead sharks; giant manta rays; the chambered nautilus; and several corals.
The ruling follows a lawsuit filed by Earthjustice on August 18, 2026, representing Fa‘asao Amerika Samoa and the Conservation Council for Hawai‘i, who argued the environmental review failed to consider all potential impacts of deep-sea mining. The Marine Minerals Administration also received over 76,000 public comments, a large majority opposing the lease sale, reflecting widespread environmental and community concerns.
Local voices emphasize cultural and ecological stakes: as Seumalu Dr. Elora Raymond of Fa‘asao Amerika Samoa notes, "American Samoans share a profound cultural and spiritual bond with the ocean." The Conservation Council for Hawai‘i’s Jonee Peters added, "Keeping this marine ecosystem pristine and intact is vital and should not be harmed by any speculative industry." The ruling significantly influences how environmental compliance is ensured in deep-sea resource development.
By the numbers:
- 31 million acres — total seabed covered by proposed lease sale
- Over 76,000 — public comments received on the deep-sea mining proposal
- $3 million — minimum bid for each of the two auctioned lease areas
Yes, but: The ruling does not cancel the lease sale outright but requires NMFS to conduct a more comprehensive environmental review, potentially delaying the auction.
What's next: The Marine Minerals Administration is expected to revise its environmental review following the court order, which may delay the scheduled November 19 lease sale.