Ninth Circuit Delays Decision on Back Pay in Religious Vaccine Mandate Case
The Ninth Circuit postponed a ruling on back pay claims tied to religious vaccine mandate disputes.
Why it matters: This highlights ongoing legal challenges in balancing religious rights against public health requirements, crucial for employment law and compliance with religious accommodation requests.
- On November 18, 2026, the Ninth Circuit postponed ruling on back pay claims from San Francisco workers resisting COVID-19 vaccine mandates on religious grounds.
- In September 2026, the Ninth Circuit upheld a $7.8 million jury award for six BART employees fired after denial of religious vaccine exemptions.
- An August 2026 Ninth Circuit panel ruled a Catholic vaccine objection did not legally qualify as a religious belief under California employment law.
- The EEOC in May 2026 found the Bureau of Indian Education unlawfully denied religious vaccine accommodations, constituting discrimination.
On November 18, 2026, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals postponed ruling on back pay claims brought by San Francisco city and county workers who challenged COVID-19 vaccine mandates on the basis of religious objections.
The court recognized that forcing workers to choose between their religious beliefs and jobs creates a substantial burden on religion. However, the panel declined to resolve the back pay issue at this stage, emphasizing the delicate balance courts must strike between protecting religious freedom and enforcing public health policies.
Back pay claims involve compensation for lost wages due to termination or suspension related to religious objections. 'Religious accommodation' means employers must make reasonable adjustments unless it causes undue hardship.
This case follows several significant rulings in 2026. In September, the same court affirmed a $7.8 million jury verdict for six Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) employees who were dismissed after their requests for religious vaccine exemptions were denied. This verdict reinforced employees' rights to religious accommodation under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act.
Meanwhile, in August 2026, a split Ninth Circuit panel ruled against a Catholic employee who argued that his anti-vaccine stance qualified as a religious belief under California law. The court decided his objection did not meet the legal criteria for a sincerely held religious belief, underscoring the fine legal distinctions involved.
At the federal agency level, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) found in May 2026 that the Department of the Interior's Bureau of Indian Education unlawfully discriminated against employees by denying their requests for religious vaccine accommodations, violating federal anti-discrimination laws.
Collectively, these decisions reveal unsettled legal terrain for employers and counsel navigating religious accommodation claims amid vaccine mandates. Employment lawyers must carefully assess such claims and the risks of litigation given evolving judicial interpretations.
By the numbers:
- $7.8 million — jury verdict affirmed by Ninth Circuit for BART employees denied religious vaccine exemptions
- November 18, 2026 — Ninth Circuit delayed ruling on back pay in San Francisco workers’ religious vaccine mandate case
- May 2026 — EEOC found federal agency unlawfully denied religious vaccine accommodations
Yes, but: While the Ninth Circuit has shown support for religious accommodation rights, it remains cautious about awarding back pay, reflecting judicial concerns about complicating public health enforcement.
What's next: Further appeals and rulings are expected as courts refine standards for religious exemptions and compensation in vaccine mandate cases.