Ninth Circuit Orders Reconsideration in Hispanic Voter Dilution Case in Washington

3 min readSources: Courthouse News

The Ninth Circuit remanded a Hispanic voter dilution suit under the Voting Rights Act in Washington.

Why it matters: This decision affects legal strategies on minority voting rights and redistricting, shaping political representation in diverse communities.

  • The Ninth Circuit remanded Palmer v. Trevino on November 19, 2026, to reconsider Hispanic voter dilution claims.
  • Plaintiffs argue Washington’s Yakima Valley redistricting violated the Voting Rights Act by splitting Hispanic voters.
  • The U.S. Supreme Court vacated the Ninth Circuit’s prior ruling, citing Louisiana v. Callais, and sent the case back in October 2026.
  • Washington enacted and strengthened the Voting Rights Act (WVRA) in 2018 and 2023, including preclearance rules effective July 2026.

On November 19, 2026, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals remanded Palmer v. Trevino to the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington's Tacoma division for further proceedings.

The case centers on allegations by plaintiffs Susan Soto Palmer and others that Washington state’s redistricting in the Yakima Valley diluted Hispanic voting power, violating the federal Voting Rights Act (VRA). The state's actions reportedly split Hispanic voters among districts, undermining their ability to elect preferred candidates.

Previously, the U.S. Supreme Court vacated the Ninth Circuit's earlier ruling and remanded the case for reconsideration following its decision in Louisiana v. Callais on October 5, 2026.

In response to Voting Rights concerns, in March 2024, U.S. District Court Judge Robert Lasnik approved a new legislative map aimed at providing Hispanic voters in Yakima Valley an equal opportunity to elect candidates of choice. Washington's own WVRA, enacted in 2018 and strengthened in 2023 by HB 1048, further bolsters protections for minority voters. It imposes preclearance requirements for jurisdictions including Yakima County, effective July 1, 2026.

Advocates emphasize the significance of the ruling. Annabelle Harless, Director of Redistricting at Campaign Legal Center, stated, "We won this case twice already, and we intend to win again. Latino voters in Yakima Valley had an equal voice for the first time in decades." MALDEF's Western Regional Counsel Ernest Herrera reiterated the importance of fair maps guaranteed by the VRA.

This remand signals ongoing judicial scrutiny of redistricting practices affecting Hispanic voters and reinforces efforts to ensure equitable electoral representation in Washington and beyond.

By the numbers:

  • November 19, 2026 — Ninth Circuit remand date for Palmer v. Trevino
  • April 13, 2023 — Washington HB 1048 enacted to strengthen Voting Rights Act
  • July 1, 2026 — Preclearance requirements under Washington Voting Rights Act take effect

Yes, but: The Supreme Court’s ruling in Louisiana v. Callais requires reconsideration but does not resolve the underlying merits of the voter dilution claim, leaving final outcomes uncertain.

What's next: The U.S. District Court for Western Washington will reconsider the case details and determine the validity of alleged Voting Rights Act violations after the remand.