Seventh Circuit: Firing Woman for IVF Violates Pregnancy Discrimination Act
The Seventh Circuit in Hall v. Nalco Co. held firing a woman for IVF violates the Pregnancy Discrimination Act.
Why it matters: Employers and in-house counsel must update policies to treat IVF as protected medical care under federal law, avoiding discrimination claims. HR professionals face increased compliance obligations as fertility treatments gain legal recognition.
- The Seventh Circuit’s 2008 ruling in Hall v. Nalco Co. found that firing an employee for IVF can violate the Pregnancy Discrimination Act (PDA).
- The PDA forbids discrimination based on pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical conditions, including fertility treatments like IVF.
- New Jersey law (NJLAD and PWFA) also mandates accommodations and bans discrimination against pregnant and breastfeeding workers within its jurisdiction.
- The ruling affirms IVF’s status as a pregnancy-related medical condition, but its binding effect is limited to the Seventh Circuit states.
- Legal experts Jennifer M. Adams and a second analyst emphasize the ruling’s importance for guiding workplace fertility treatment accommodations.
The Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals, in the case of Hall v. Nalco Co. (2008), ruled that terminating a woman because she was undergoing in vitro fertilization (IVF) violated the federal Pregnancy Discrimination Act (PDA). The PDA is a federal law that prohibits discrimination "because of or on the basis of pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical conditions." This ruling clarified that IVF qualifies as a pregnancy-related medical condition entitled to protection.
Legal expert Jennifer M. Adams, who specializes in reproductive rights, explains that this decision extends PDA protections to fertility treatments such as IVF. She emphasizes that employers in the Seventh Circuit, which covers Illinois, Indiana, and Wisconsin, should accommodate employees undergoing fertility treatment just as they would other pregnancy-related care.
Another independent legal analyst agrees, noting the case sets an important precedent for workplace protections involving reproductive technologies. However, this ruling is binding only within the Seventh Circuit’s jurisdiction and does not automatically apply nationwide.
Separately, states like New Jersey have enacted their own protections. The New Jersey Law Against Discrimination (NJLAD) and the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA) require employers to provide reasonable accommodations and forbid adverse treatment of pregnant and breastfeeding workers within New Jersey.
For in-house counsel and HR teams, this ruling signals the need to review policies on fertility treatments and pregnancy accommodations. Employers must avoid adverse actions against employees undergoing IVF to mitigate legal risk in the Seventh Circuit states.
This case highlights evolving interpretations of pregnancy discrimination law as reproductive technologies develop. It offers guidance for bridging the gap between medical advances in fertility and workplace protections.
By the numbers:
- 2008 — Year of Seventh Circuit ruling in Hall v. Nalco Co.
- 3 — States covered by Seventh Circuit jurisdiction (Illinois, Indiana, Wisconsin)
- 2 — New Jersey laws (NJLAD, PWFA) augment federal pregnancy discrimination protections
Yes, but: The ruling applies only within the Seventh Circuit; courts in other circuits may interpret pregnancy discrimination and IVF protections differently.
What's next: Legal teams should monitor if other circuits adopt similar interpretations or if federal legislation explicitly addresses fertility treatments under pregnancy discrimination law.