Supreme Court's performance questions need for some reforms like court-packing

3 min readSources: Volokh Conspiracy, SCOTUSblog

Analysis finds Supreme Court's record undermines proposals like court-packing.

Why it matters: Understanding the Court's current performance is key for legal professionals and policymakers debating reforms amid political pressures. This context helps assess which reforms may be effective or misplaced.

  • 53% of Americans held an unfavorable view of the Supreme Court as of July 2026.
  • Gallup found only 34% approved of the Court’s job performance in September 2026, a historic low.
  • The Court shifted sharply right between 2020-2021 but moderated conservatism in 2023 after backlash to Dobbs v. Mississippi.
  • Supreme Court issued more substantive rulings via its 'shadow docket' than in open court during the 2024-2025 term.
  • Experts argue some reform ideas, such as court-packing, are poor responses despite low ratings.

The U.S. Supreme Court faces historically low approval ratings, with a July 2026 Pew survey showing 53% of Americans hold an unfavorable opinion, while a Gallup poll from September 2026 reports only 34% approval, the lowest since 1972.

The Court’s ideological stance swung sharply rightward following Justice Amy Coney Barrett’s 2020-2021 appointment, according to a detailed analysis from Harvard Kennedy School. However, in 2023, it moderated its conservative position after backlash over the Dobbs v. Mississippi ruling which overturned Roe v. Wade.

Increasingly, the Court issues substantive rulings via its controversial "shadow docket," handling more emergency decisions than those argued openly, as revealed by investigative reporting from ProPublica during the 2024-2025 term.

In response to low public confidence, several reform proposals surfaced, including 18-year judicial term limits, ethics codes, increased transparency on emergency rulings, expanding justices' numbers, and allowing cameras in oral arguments, as analyzed by Court Docket.

Yet some legal experts challenge the effectiveness of certain reforms. George Mason Law Professor Ilya Somin argues the Court’s performance, though imperfect, is adequate to reject radical measures like court-packing. Harvard Law’s Nancy Gertner warns commentators often normalize an "abnormal" Court, suggesting some perceptions may be inflated.

Meanwhile, Michael Waldman of the Brennan Center acknowledges public demand for a better Court and notes political attention to these concerns. This discourse adds nuance to reform debates, emphasizing measured responses over sweeping structural changes.

By the numbers:

  • 53% — Americans with an unfavorable view of the Supreme Court as of July 2026
  • 34% — Approval rating of the Supreme Court's job performance in September 2026 (historic low)
  • More substantive rulings on the shadow docket than in open court — 2024-2025 term

Yes, but: While some experts reject court-packing, declining public trust and the Court's reliance on shadow docket rulings highlight enduring legitimacy challenges.

What's next: Ongoing discussions about Supreme Court reforms will continue, focusing on ethics codes, transparency, term limits, and potentially expanding justices.